Unimaginable

September 27, 2021 5 Comments

The light was strange. I walked the Sandy River delta for the first time since January, so grateful to be back and a bit worried if I had the strength for the full round in the 90 degree September heat. Thoughts of the fragility of existence, my companions for too long, were underscored by the wind that came down from the mountains, making the dry branches and grasses bending and trembling, the poplars noisy with their rattling silver leaves, upended by the gusts.

Claude Monet Haystacks 1885

The gusts were hints of colder times, easily ignored during this endless summer, perhaps perceived only because my thoughts were swirling around the essay I’ll urge you to read today, if you have time to read anything (I’ll keep my own remarks correspondingly short.) Robert Kagan, senior fellow at the Brookings Institute and a neoconservative scholar, lays out what quite likely might be ahead for us as a country, and it is frightening to hear its measured analysis by a conservative, no less.

Ermenoville, Department Oise

Yes, politics. Yes, more bad news. Yes, I know the feeling of not wanting to hear one more scary thing in a world full of them.

Claude Monet Poplars at Giverny 1887

Do read it.

Camille Pissaro Poplars, Eragny 1895

You want to be prepared for what one might once thought unimaginable. Even though it is tempting to ignore that there is always a second act in the wings. One we might not like.

I might mention the German election results in passing…. major parties had a head-to head competition with a razor thin edge going, for now, to the Social Democrats – a centrist party who will need to form a coalition with any number of smaller parties to govern, an unwieldy moloch marked by political compromises. All signs point to continuation of the familiar paths rather than radical re-orientation in view of the needed actions for climate change. For me the most frightening number was the fact that among those voting for the first time a higher number picked a business friendly, conservative party (FDP) over the Green Party – so much for the “youth will save us.” And two large states in the Eastern parts of the country, Thuringia and Saxony, went all in for the right-wing extremist AfD. Berlin will have a mayor whose phD title was rescinded for plagiarism and who gave up her ministerial seat as minister for family in the wake of the scandal, now to oversee the government of the capital.

Claude Monet Wind effect (Poplar Series) 1891

I’ll sweeten the reading assignment with some classic paintings of poplars that were brought to mind by the beauty in front of my eyes – in black and white to emphasize the structure and pattern (and similarities) of these wispy trees.

Vincent van Gogh Poplars at St. Remy 1889

Maybe the river will have water again (photograph of the tree lined water is from 2 years ago around this time) – right now it is unimaginably low.

Claude Monet Poplars at the Epte 1891
Vincent van Gogh Poplars near Nuenen 1884

Soon the trees will shed their leaves, and the scent of decaying silver and gold will emanate from the layers and layers that soften your step. I’ll be out there again, soon.

Paul Gauguin Landscape with Poplars 1875

Today’s music acknowledges that somehow most of these paintings seem to have originated in France, even though Germany and the PNW is full of poplars as well. The selection of pieces by Ravel is quite representative of his best work.

Sue Darius Lombardy Poplars

And here is a poem from the late 1800s :

Binsey Poplars

BY GERARD MANLEY HOPKINS

felled 1879

My aspens dear, whose airy cages quelled, 
  Quelled or quenched in leaves the leaping sun, 
  All felled, felled, are all felled; 
    Of a fresh and following folded rank 
                Not spared, not one 
                That dandled a sandalled 
         Shadow that swam or sank 
On meadow & river & wind-wandering weed-winding bank. 

  O if we but knew what we do 
         When we delve or hew — 
     Hack and rack the growing green! 
          Since country is so tender 
     To touch, her being só slender, 
     That, like this sleek and seeing ball 
     But a prick will make no eye at all, 
     Where we, even where we mean 
                 To mend her we end her, 
            When we hew or delve: 
After-comers cannot guess the beauty been. 
  Ten or twelve, only ten or twelve 
     Strokes of havoc unselve 
           The sweet especial scene, 
     Rural scene, a rural scene, 
     Sweet especial rural scene. 

September 24, 2021
September 29, 2021

friderikeheuer@gmail.com

5 Comments

  1. Reply

    Louise A Palermo

    September 27, 2021

    Perfect images and image companions. I will read your essay, but with sadness. Then I will go back to these images and hope.

  2. Reply

    Carl Wolfsohn

    September 27, 2021

    Beautiful photos! Thank you! I read Kagan’s op-ed when it ran in The Washington Post. We should at least be grateful for the alarm bells from all quarters. We need eternal vigilance and activism to defeat the cancer of Trumpism, the current iteration of a familiar evil. I am far less worried about Germany; when you add vote totals of Greens, center-left, and center-right there is an overwhelming commitment to rational governance. In the U.S., one of our two political parties has accepted lawlessness at its core.

  3. Reply

    Anita Helle

    September 27, 2021

    Thank you, thank you for this gift of the poplars in their “airy cages.” Your third sentence–so beautiful. And for your take on the German elections.

  4. Reply

    Steve T.

    September 27, 2021

    Thanks for this YDP, Friderike. Kagan’s essay is frightening; but there is a small part of me that says if right-wing leaders can see what trump et al want to do, maybe they and Dems will work together to stop it. I worry for my grandchildren.

  5. Reply

    Sara Lee Silberman

    September 27, 2021

    A confession: I did not have the stomach to read the Kagan piece word for word, but a skimming of it is enough both to terrify me (again!) and to persuade me that Kagan is right on the money. It is truly mind-blowing and terrifying – that word comes to mind again – to contemplate both what has happened to this country since 1/20/’17 and the fact that neither political party seems, as Kagan claims, committed to doing what’s necessary to save constitutional government.
    Thank goodness for balm and beauty of the poplars you provided!

LEAVE A COMMENT

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

RELATED POST