“The sociopathic hierarchies our culture has inherited were invented by a people taught that they were separate from, and likely condemned by, the very thing which had created them—and in response to their disenfranchisement they built a ladder, and dominated every rung they perceived as beneath them; because the sense of superiority masked the pain of disconnection. But, like any masked thing, the fact of its existence remains and, whether engaged with or not, pain always finds a way to be expressed. Ecocide, then, is the logical conclusion to this severance—if that which created us will not love us, better to kill it, than feel the pain of its refusal. Ecocide is deicide is suicide. It is our collective response to feeling orphaned, and not knowing how to be with the grief of it. The tragedy, of course—beside the mountains of dead and dying, and the silence where once there was birdsong—is that it was never even true. That we have always belonged, more completely than we could bear, but that we were handed a set of goggles many generations ago, and we’re still wondering around thinking they’re our eyes.” – Chloe Hope

***

Before it got too hot last week, I hiked along the Columbia river at Beacon Rock State Park, named after a large rock already mentioned in Lewis&Clark’s diaries in 1805 during their westward expedition. A short drive away from Portland into Skamania County, WA, you can dwell on both nature and history.

The nature is gorgeous, the history rotten, what else is new.

The Yakima Treaty of Camp Stevens in 1855 forced the tribal owners of the land – the Sahaptian and Coast Salish Indigenous people – to cede their land. In 1865 the land passed into private ownership, with frontage on the Columbia River, including the Indigenous village below Beacon Rock, claimed under the terms of the Donation Land Claim Act, which codified land claims for the earliest American migrants into the area.

Various private investors across the decades bought and and often defaulted on land and timber parcels or tax loads. In 1929, Spencer Biddle and Rebecca Biddle Wood, then private owners of Beacon Rock, offered it as a land donation to the State of Washington for a State Park. Governor Roland H. Hartle refused the donation. Only when the Superintendent of Oregon State Parks tried to acquire the land, did public opinion force a shift of the Washington State administration which finally agreed to a state park in 1935. (Ref.)

The meadows were filled with daisies, the air full of birdsong, small tributaries gurgling into the larger river. The breeze had the aspen and alder leaves turn, shimmering silvery in the early afternoon light. It was quiet, few hikers out and the rock climbing side of the rock closed to protect nesting falcons.

Across the river you could see the burnt forests of the Gorge, making me think about current administration attempts to dismantle the US Forest Service—shuttering 57 research labs, relocating HQ, and forcing out thousands of federal workers, including woodland firefighters. (Congress could, of course, stop this sabotage.)

How can one possibly explain the rationale for curtailing protection for our lands (and the workers and citizens tied to it? Is it as simple as for-profit motives, or anti-science bent? Refusing to acknowledge the reality of climate change which will increase the need for fire fighting, among others, and more rather than less forest management geared towards meeting the changing needs, to extract the very last penny from the land, acquiescing to certain eventual collapse?

What happened, considering that previous Republican administrations were instrumental in helping science along, now actively in the process of being dismantled not just for forests and agriculture, but weather research, ocean monitoring, food safety, and of course issues related to disease, from prevention to treatment, vaccination to the availability of new drugs. After all, the National Academy of Sciences was founded in the Lincoln administration; NASA in the Eisenhower administration, and PEPFAR (U.S. President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief), PMI (President’s Malaria Initiative) and the NTDs (neglected tropical diseases) program were launched in the George W. Bush Administration.

Some trace the adoption of anti-science stance as a major platform of the GOP to the year 2015 when the antivaccine movement pivoted to political extremism on the right. It continued massively during the Covid pandemic and the perceived curtailing of “freedom” with mask mandates, public closures, social distancing and vaccination requirements. These days the anti-science sentiment has reached a fever pitch, not just nationally. It’s going global risking hundreds of thousands of lives.

A lot of it, alas, has to do with religion. The evangelical hard right claims that science is not only anathema to faith, but actively trying to undermine it. It can’t be trusted (Science is a hoax! Just look at how it changes its finding all the time!). Worse, it is a secular tool to lure people away from the “right” Christian path.

There are additional factors at work, though. One, if you are a member of a group (or a child raised there) that has certain attitudes, you will adopt them for group cohesion and a sense of belonging. And secondly, it is always hard to engage with some new facts or insights that very much contradict your current thinking. (True for all of us.) That is particularly true for people who were raised with or have personalities favoring rigid belief systems rather than flexible openness to the new and different. In other words, it’s hard to get scientific information to stick when it raises the possibility of conflict within a person’s assumptions about the world as it is and SHOULD be.

All the more so, when you think of your world as a hierarchical system where you perceive “elites” associated with science/scientists as looking down on you or pulling the wool over your eyes. If the world is perceived to be a ladder, not only does it help your sense of worth mistreating those on rungs beneath you. Just think how great it’ll make you feel if you can punish those who you assume are above, ready to stomp.

“Let’s burn it all down. That’ll show them who has the power…”

Well, burn it will, and everyone, no exemption, will be harmed by level 3 evacuations or the loss of public lands that have sustained Americans for centuries, and the Native tribes for millennia before that. All in the wake of climate change denial and anti-science rage. Never mind greed.

Music today by a Portland treasure.